Missing New York woman found in Adair County


ADAIR COUNTY — A missing woman from New York was located in Adair County on Saturday.

According to police, Guthrie County Dispatch dispatched officers with the Stuart Police Department to the Casey’s Store located in the 700 block of South Division Street where a woman had called 911.

Officers made contact with the caller, Amber Garrison, of Smyrna, New York. Garrison told officers that she had been kidnapped from a truck stop in Pennsylvania in mid-July. She told officers that she had been assaulted several times and was forced to stay to remain with the truck driver through multiple states.

Garrison had reported that she had called 911 several times before that in Adair County but according to officials the caller did not speak and the dispatched officer was not able to find her exact location.

Garrison had several injuries and was transported to Adair County Hospital for treatment.

A search warrant was conducted of the semi and evidence was discovered. The driver, James Scott Smith Jr. of Mexico, New York, was arrested. Smith Jr. has been charged with kidnapping in the first degree, harassment in the first degree, domestic assault with a weapon and obstruction of emergency communication.

Local 5 has obtained court documents related to this case. Here’s what police have reported:

-Garrison said that James Scott Smith Jr. picked her up from a truck stop in Pennslyvania on July 20 after meeting Smith Jr. on a dating app.

-Garrison stated that once she was in the semi truck cab with Smith, she was not allowed to leave.

-Garrison told police that she was not allowed to use her cell phone or contact family, until Smith allegedly realized that she was listed as a missing person through the State of New York.

-Garrison said that Smith told her to call her mother and tell her that she was not missing. According to Garrison, Smith told her to email a New York State Trooper and state that she was not missing.

-Garrison told police that Smith allegedly forced her to have sex with him. Smith allegedly would beat Garrison or threaten her with a knife.

-Smith told police that the relationship was consensual.

-Garrison stated to police that Smith let her go after she promised she wouldn’t call police at the Casey’s gas station. When Garrison was located by police on August 31 in Stuart, she had visible injuries on numerous locations on her body, including blood coming from both her nostrils, a red mark on her face, a red abrasion on her left upper breast and a bruise on her left upper calf. Garrison, according to police, also complained of a possible infection on her left forearm and left thumb, where she said that Smith forcefully tattooed her.

James Scott Smith Jr.

Garrison had been reported missing to the New York State Police in early August. According to the New York State Police, Garrison’s mom reported her missing in August. She hadn’t seen her daughter in three weeks, but told authorities that was not uncommon. Local 5 has also confirmed that while missing, the New York State Police said Garrison or someone from her Facebook account messaged Garrison’s mom a few times. On at least one occasion, police said the person asked Garrison’s mom to take down the missing person posts.

According to New York state police, they do not believe any crimes were committed in New York State. A post on the state police Facebook page in mid-August said that Garrison “was last seen at the Super 8 motel in Norwich on August 9, 2019 but has not had any contact with family since July 19, 2019.”

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Trending Stories

Donate Today